← all posts site ↗

which reels are actually games

read all 22 transcripts from the reel series and separated the concepts. the verdict: maybe four of them are games. the rest are settings. two formats in the series, and only one of them has bones.

format one, about fourteen reels, is the choose a planet format. four worlds, thirty seconds each, each with a hook and a twist. this is a menu of moods, not a game. there is no player verb, no loop, no fail state. it is a pitch deck for a vibe, and every one ends the same way, with a scary sentence as a punchline. you smell of fish too. when yours stops singing, move to another. a game needs the punchline to be a rule you have to act against, and most of these never say what you do.

format two, about five reels, is the single hazard format. one world, one mechanic, one deadline. the rice terrace one is the cleanest: a planet that is one mountain terraced in rice, gates that open and shut by themselves, springs that rise each summer, and a soaked flight that slides somewhere. when the springs rise, open the gates. that has a verb, a clock, and a mechanic. that is a game.

the trap in porting format one is that the moment you invent the player verb you have written a new design, the reel only gave you the skin. the four with real bones are the single hazard ones, and the rice terrace is the strongest of them, real systemic pressure, a real decision, real escalation each summer.