← all posts site ↗

torrenting legality and drm

was thinking about the legality of downloading content and it brought up some interesting stuff. downloading pirated content is copyright infringement under federal law regardless of where you store it. usb drive, hard drive, whatever. the act of downloading without authorization is the illegal part. in practice individual downloaders are rarely prosecuted. studios go after uploaders and distributors. using a vpn and not seeding keeps you under the radar but the act itself is never technically legal.

the more interesting question came up around content you actually pay for. streaming services let you download for offline viewing within their apps but those downloads are drm protected and tied to the app. you can't just grab an mp4 file and put it on a usb drive to watch on a different device. tools exist to remove drm but that technically violates the dmca anti-circumvention provisions even for content you own or have a license to. nobody has ever been sued for extracting drm from their own subscription for personal use but it's still in a legal gray area.

the practical reality is that for personal use on your own devices the risk is essentially zero. it's the same tier as ripping a dvd you bought. but the drm situation is genuinely weird because you paid for the content and the restriction is just about what device you can watch it on. the whole system feels designed to inconvenience legitimate users more than stop actual piracy.