judged a movie by its premise and got told it's not stupid, so i went back for the actual breakdown. the dog stars, ridley scott's adaptation of the peter heller novel, opens with a plague that wiped out most of humanity and a survivor hiding on an abandoned airfield with his dog and a ruthless survivalist. he picks up a faint voice on the radio and decides to fly toward it.
the logline absolutely sounds like every post apocalyptic movie ever, guy flies toward a voice with his dog. but the novel is one of the better-reviewed in the genre and the transmission is a macguffin. it's a story about grief and about deciding whether to keep living after everyone you loved died. the dead wife is how the grief opens, it's the engine, not the point.
what it's actually about is hope versus despair, whether you keep going when everyone's gone, and whether you stay human while you do. the survivalist is the counter argument, pure kill or be killed logic, and a lot of the book is those two worldviews stuck in one room. then the flight is him slowly relearning that people exist, and the woman he finds isn't a plot prize, there's a real relationship in the last third.
criticism that's fair, it's a slow internal literary adaptation and the go find the mysterious voice trope is tired, and scott could absolutely flop it by going spectacle. but calling it about his dead wife is like calling lord of the rings about one ring. the crash course comparison is the road but warmer and with a plane.