read up on the lindsay clancy murder trial closing. back in january 2023 in massachusetts, she strangled her three kids in the basement with exercise bands while her husband ran errands she sent him on, then tried to kill herself, cutting her wrists and neck and jumping from a second floor window. the fall paralyzed her from the waist down.
the charges are three counts of first degree murder plus three counts of strangulation, and the defense admits she did it. this is not a whodunit at all. the whole fight is over criminal responsibility, which is massachusetts's version of the insanity standard. a guilty verdict means mandatory life with no parole. a not criminally responsible verdict sends her to a state psychiatric facility instead.
the defense points at untreated postpartum psychosis, a spiraling mental state, a pile of medications, hospital stays, suicide hotline calls, and a voice she reported hearing telling her to kill the kids so she could kill herself. the prosecution says she was deeply depressed but not insane, and points at planning: her searches about arteries and disabling car airbags, and maps timed to her husband's roughly forty five minute errand run. the closing reporting reads like the jury weighing whether the awfulness of the act itself is the proof of the madness.