asked for a pile of examples of new technology eating an older industry, tractor versus horse farming, photography versus painting, containerization versus the longshoremen, streaming versus blockbuster, generative ai versus stack overflow. they all follow the same shape. the new thing starts cheap and crappy, the incumbent ignores it, then it gets good enough and takes the market. and the incumbent almost always saw it coming. the film company knew about digital. the messenger service knew about the telephone. they just could not cannibalize their own cash cow, so someone from outside the industry did it for them.
but then i pushed on what this does to the people and the knowledge. does skill transfer upward? mostly no. the individual's knowledge floor usually drops first, the handloom weaver became a factory hand, not an engineer. the upskilled roles went to the next generation with fresh education. craft detail always migrates into the tool, which is really the definition of technology. telephone operators memorized whole exchanges and now it is a button. morse code was an entire profession and then it was destroyed outright.
the interesting question is what remains when the how gets automated. the answer i keep landing on is judgment, knowing what is worth making and when the tool is wrong. that layer never devalues, it compounds. and each disruption feels scarier than the last because the absorb window keeps shrinking, tractors gave agriculture decades, spreadsheets gave bookkeeping maybe fifteen years, and generative ai might give a lot of analysis work about four.
lastly, abundance never actually devalues the thing, it splits it in two. the artifact goes to zero price but scarcity relocates upward to taste, curation, attention. the survivors of any wave win the distribution, not the means. and the devalued craft becomes the floor of the next bigger thing, photography devalued painting and then became the floor for film and games. the middle gets squeezed to a power law and difficulty comes back as luxury, which is why film and vinyl quietly returned.