asked for the real comparison between the liquid sucralose i've used in every coffee for two years and xylitol, because xylitol picked up a scary headline this year. verdict on the splenda: keep it. the dose is so small it's nowhere near the acceptable daily intake, and the insulin controversy in the literature only shows up when sucralose is consumed alongside carbohydrate, which black coffee isn't. the concerns that apply are for sucralose in sweetened products with actual sugar present, not a few drops in a cup of coffee.
xylitol is the one that genuinely changed my mind. a research group tied higher circulating xylitol to a higher rate of cardiovascular events and then showed the mechanism, a xylitol sweetened drink made blood platelets more reactive in every healthy volunteer tested, which is direct experimental evidence, not just association. and the body makes far less of it than you get from eating it, so the signal really is dietary. it stays the gold standard for dental use, rinsing and gum at tiny doses is a different risk profile, but i'm done swallowing it as a bulk sugar swap.
so the split is clean now. splenda stays in the coffee because it's inert there. allulose becomes the choice for sweetening anything that already has carbs, because it's the only one that actively softens the spike. xylitol gets demoted from eat freely to dental tool only. the answer was basically, don't fix the coffee, fix the other uses.