← all posts site ↗

skill elimination is not new

when a skill dies, the people who held it lose, usually permanently, and the value re-founds one rung higher. this has happened before and it has looked like the endpoint every single time. portrait painting died to photography, the likeness craft was erased in a generation, the journeyman portrait painter as a class ended, and painting relocated into impressionism, into vision instead of fidelity. typesetters died to phototypesetting with no artistic rebound, the career just ended. switchboard operators too. it's a whole graveyard.

the counterproof is the machinist. cnc didn't kill the trade, it re-specified the skill upward into programming and setup, and survivors earn more because a judgment layer survived the automation. translation is being cut to the floor right now by machine translation, and only the premium literary work and the pipeline owners survive. the law across all of it is one sentence. measurable output, fidelity, speed, accuracy, kills the skill as a livelihood. unmeasurable output, taste, feel, vision, survives and revalues. and the middle skill practitioner is the casualty, every single time.

applied to making games, programming is the typesetter, it dies in its fidelity form. design, direction, and feel are the painter's vision, that layer survives. so the concrete move is to ship one tiny game end to end in a couple weeks, not as a masterpiece but as a test. one mechanic you already find fun, cut ruthlessly, published somewhere free with no store page, and you use it to answer which seat you actually sit in. that's the whole point of it, the test is the product.

because there are two seats left and one of them is yours. the rail seat, distribution, platform, ownership, audience routing, which is where the money lives. or the judgment seat, the person who owns an audience and decides what deserves to exist. both beat being the best artisan of a dying measurement. making was always the tool, routing is the strategy. ship the thing, see who shows up, and pick a seat instead of waffling between them, because waffling is the only failure mode that actually loses.