had this image in my head of a modern musician unexpectedly rising from the ocean to perform in the middle of a medieval ship battle. spent a long time trying to figure out what the game actually is. started with rhythm survival where you stand on debris and play guitar to raise a shield, but that felt like guitar hero with a fancy background. tried a tug-of-war concept where you buff whichever fleet you face while the other shoots you in the back, but that was still pretty surface level.
the breakthrough was realizing the music should not be a mechanic on top of the battle. the music should be the battle. two fleets fighting to control your song. each fleet has a pattern they are trying to impose on you — one pushes slow heavy doom metal, the other pushes fast chaotic flamenco. when you play their pattern, their ships react. the slow pattern makes water surge and waves crash into enemy ships. the fast pattern makes cannons misfire and ships explode from within. but you can only build one pattern at a time, and switching mid-song wastes whatever you had building.
the camera is pulled back near-isometric showing the stage in the center as a glowing circle on the water, ships on either side, half-sunk wrecks bobbing around. the unique tension is that you are not picking a side. you are trying to play your own music while two armies force-feed you their battle hymns. if you play your own original riff you do not hurt either fleet directly but instead heal the ocean and grow your stage. ignore a fleet's pattern too long and they start targeting you specifically. the tone is dark comedy plus genuine tension — a touring musician who fell off a ferry thinking i really should have taken that bus to portland. each battle is one song, short sessions, with the stage getting progressively stranger as something ancient in the ocean starts recognizing the melody.