the extreme cut approach means very high protein, low fat, and very low carbs. it works for fast initial weight loss because glycogen depletion causes water loss and the scale drops quickly in the first two weeks. protein and fat have higher satiety per calorie and ketosis from near zero carbs kills hunger. the thermic effect of protein means about twenty to thirty percent of its calories are lost to digestion versus five to ten percent for carbs and fat. muscle sparing works in the short term with high protein intake.
but the metabolic risks are real. low carbs suppress t3 which is the active thyroid hormone. calorie deficit plus carb restriction is a double hit to metabolic rate. non-exercise activity thermogenesis drops and you feel cold lethargic and foggy. cortisol increases significantly in the first weeks of low carb diets and elevated cortisol causes muscle catabolism, water retention, poor sleep, and mood disruption. testosterone gets suppressed with low carbs plus deficit which undermines muscle retention and recovery.
gluconeogenesis is the hidden killer. when carbs are near zero the liver converts amino acids from that expensive protein into glucose. you are literally burning protein for energy which is the exact thing high protein intake is supposed to prevent. muscles look flat because glycogen stores deplete and each gram of glycogen binds about three grams of water. the brain runs on glucose and low blood sugar disturbs cognition and mood. extended extreme cuts cause adaptive thermogenesis where the body learns to run on less and post diet fat regain happens faster.
mike mentzer advocated for higher carbs than protein. his approach was about six hundred calories per day with fifty to sixty percent carbs, fifteen to twenty five percent protein, and fifteen to thirty five percent fat. he ate ice cream and baked potatoes while getting shredded. his reasoning was that weight training burns glycogen not fat so carbs fuel the anaerobic work. carbs spare protein from being burned for energy. glycogen fills muscles with water for a full hard vascular look even at low body fat. modern research validates this because when calories are equated macro ratios don't significantly change fat loss outcomes but they do change hormonal response and muscle retention.