can't tell if someone's a creatine non-responder without a muscle biopsy. practical proxy: if you eat 1.5-2 lbs of meat daily, you're probably already near saturation. vegetarians almost always respond because they're starting from a lower baseline. the only real test is tracking strength over 4 weeks and seeing if anything moves. supplements are a scam until proven otherwise.
which is annoying because i just started taking it again and now i'm wondering if i'm wasting money. the math says i eat enough meat that i might already be saturated. but the math also said my bluetooth rssi should decrease with distance so maybe the math is wrong about everything. the literature says loading phase (20g/day for a week) saturates muscles faster but maintenance dose (5g/day) gets you there eventually anyway. so the loading phase is just a faster way to the same place.
the real question isn't whether creatine works — it's one of the most studied supplements with decades of evidence. the question is whether it works for someone who already eats a high-protein diet with adequate meat intake. the answer is probably "a little bit" which isn't enough to justify the bloating and water retention you get in the first two weeks. but then again, 5% improvement on a compound lift over 12 weeks is meaningful in a way that "a little bit" undersells.
started tracking this week. 5g daily, same time, with food. if my bench doesn't move 5lbs in a month i'm blaming the bluetooth rssi model for lowering my faith in quantitative analysis generally.